1574 Coddington Road, Brooktondale, NY 14817

1574 Coddington Road, Brooktondale, NY 14817

$465000.00

MLS#: R1684718

List Date: May 26, 2026

List Status: Active

Contact: Cliff Roth

Descriptions

Country Living Close to Town with Magnificent Swim Pond! Bright & spacious. A natural swimming and fishing Shangri-La. Property boasts pristine private pond on 12+ acres anchored by large rustic 4BR 19th century home. 10-minutes to Ithaca. Wraparound deck. Lawns. Huge kitchen. High ceiling primary bedroom has loft, ensuite bath. Full basement. Garage. Wood stove, veranda firewood storage. 4-zone thermionic smart-home heating. Spectrum internet. Big closets, built-ins. Pick raspberries walking to secluded 18ft deep pond. Ithaca school district. Solid bones ready for your updates. A rare find!

Directions

On Coddington Rd. three houses south of E. Miller, look for flower mailbox right side of driveway.

Property Details

New York State Alliance of MLS's - Single Family (RES)

County:  Tompkins

Street #:  1574

Street Name:  Coddington Rd.

Township:  Danby

Town or City (mailing address):  Brooktondale

Postal City (Post office/mailing city):  Brooktondale

Zip Code:  14817

Tax Map Number:  502200-6.-1-29

# of Acres:  12.5

Lot:  029

Square Footage:  2200

Nearest Cross Street:  E. Miller Rd.

Lot Shape:  Rectangular

Lot Frontage:  336 feet

Lot Depth:  1587

Lot Sq. Footage:  544500

55+ Subdivision/Community:  No

Year Built:  1965

Year Built Description:  Existing Unknown

Type of Sale:  Normal

On Waterfront:  No

Waterfront Description:  Pond

School Information

School District Name:  Ithaca

High School:  Ithaca High School

Middle School:  Boynton Middle School

Elementary School:  South Hill Elementary School

General Information

Bedroom 1:  2nd Floor

Room Length:  20 feet

Room Width:  12 feet

Bedroom 2:  2nd Floor

Room Length:  16 feet

Room Width:  12 feet

Bedroom 3:  2nd Floor

Room Length:  12 feet

Room Width:  12 feet

Bedroom 4:  2nd Floor

Room Length:  12 feet

Room Width:  7 feet

Basement:  Basement

Dining Room:  1st Floor

Kitchen:  1st Floor

Living Room:  1st Floor

Room Name (other 1):  Laundry Room

Other 1-Floor/Level:  1st Floor

Bedrooms 1st Floor / Level:  0

Bedrooms 2nd Floor / Level:  4

Bedrooms 3rd Floor / Level:  0

Bedrooms 4th Floor / Level:  0

# Bedrooms Basement / Level:  0

Full Baths 1st Floor / Level:  0

Full Baths 2nd Floor / Level:  2

Full Baths 3rd Floor / Level:  0

Full Baths 4th Floor / Level:  0

# Full Baths Basement / Level:  0

Half Baths 1st Floor / Level:  1

Half Baths 2nd Floor / Level:  0

Half Baths 3rd Floor / Level:  0

Half Baths 4th Floor / Level:  0

# Half Baths Basement / Level:  0

Total Rooms:  10

Total Stories:  2

Style of Residence:  2 Story  Farmhouse

Exterior Construction:  Brick and Frame

Attic Description:  Partial  Unfinished

# Garage Spaces:  1

Garage Description:  Attached

Basement Description:  Full

Roof Description:  Shingles

Garage/Parking Amenities:  Electrical Service  Storage

Foundation Description:  Block

Driveway Description:  Stone / Gravel

Lot Information:  Horses Permitted

Interior and Exterior Information

Additional Rooms:  Laundry-1st Floor  Living Room  Loft  Master Bedroom Bath  Porch-Open

Additional Interior Features:  Ceiling Fan  Drapes-Some  Furnished-Partially  Natural Woodwork-some  Sliding Glass Door

Kitchen Dining Description:  Breakfast Room  Country Kitchen  Eat- In  Island

Kitchen Equipment / Appliances:  Convection  Dishwasher  Oven/Range Gas  Range Hood Exhaust Fan  Refrigerator

Additional Exterior Features:  Barbecue  Cable TV Available  Deck  High Speed Internet  Private Yard - See Remarks  Propane Tank - Owned

Floor Description:  Hardwood - Some  Vinyl - Some

Additional Structure:  Other

Fireplace

# Artificial:  0

# Gas:  0

# Pellet:  0

# Wood Burning:  0

# Wood Stove:  1

# Coal:  0

# Other:  0

# Free Standing:  0

# Not Represented to Code:  0

Utilities Information

HVAC Type:  AC Unit-Window  Baseboard  Hot Water  Multi-Zone  Municipal Electric  Programmable Thermostat

Water Heater/Fuel:  Oil

Sewer Description:  Septic

ENERGY STAR Qualified:  Appliances  Heating

Energy Equipment:  Oil Tank Basement  Propane Owned

HVAC/Heating Fuel Description:  Oil  Wood

Water Resources:  Well

Type of Well:  Drilled

Electric:  Available  Connected

Insulation:  Unknown

Tax Information

Possible Financing Accepted by Owner:  Cash  Commercial Loan  Conventional Loan  FHA  Private  USDA  USDA-FSA Loan

HOA Payment Frequency:  None

Assessed Value:  188000

Town/County Tax:  563.24

School Tax:  2844.31

City/Village Tax:  974.84

Annual Special Assessment:  313.12

Escrow Bank:  Chase

Escrow Agent:  na

Occupancy Information

Possession:  After Closing

Inquiry Form